Every track had to justify its inclusion. The generous playing time and concentration of proven hits gave the public an obvious reason to buy the album, while television advertising communicated that value quickly and directly.
The success of the Beach Boys album led to further television-promoted EMI compilations featuring artists including Glen Campbell, The Shadows, Diana Ross and Buddy Holly. It established a model in which older recordings could be repackaged and sold as premium products rather than relegated to the budget market.
Applying the formula in New Zealand
Peter subsequently applied the principle at EMI (New Zealand), making a strong marketing push behind releases derived from the 20 Golden Greats formula. Albums by Diana Ross, The Shadows and other established performers were promoted as substantial collections of proven material rather than inexpensive clearances of ageing recordings.
New Zealand also exposed Peter to another important development. Graham Broughton, then managing director of PolyGram New Zealand, had coordinated cooperation between record companies to produce the Solid Gold series of contemporary-hit compilations.
Because New Zealand was a relatively small market, the companies had a strong commercial incentive to cooperate. By licensing recordings to one another, they could assemble hit collections that were more attractive than anything one company could produce using only its own catalogue.
It was the first time Peter had encountered a joint venture of that kind between major record companies. The experience showed him that competitors could work together when cooperation produced a stronger product—and provided a model he would soon take with him to Australia.
Bringing the strategy to Australia
Peter transferred to EMI (Australia) in late 1979 to run the company’s recorded-music operation, remaining until March 1983. He brought with him the lessons he had absorbed from EMI’s television-marketing program in Britain and his experience applying those ideas in New Zealand.
Peter also brought with him the collaborative model he had encountered through New Zealand’s Solid Gold series. When he proposed similar joint-venture compilations in Australia, he was told that they would be impossible because the major record companies were competitors and did not cooperate closely enough to combine their most valuable contemporary recordings.
Peter nevertheless persisted, negotiating joint ventures with Festival and Warner. These arrangements allowed EMI (Australia) to assemble compilations containing major hits controlled by different companies, producing stronger and more representative collections of current music.
“I broke that mould,” he recalled.
The resulting releases included 1980… The Music, 1981… The Sound and 1982… With a Bullet. Rather than being collections of secondary material, the albums were promoted as snapshots of each year’s popular music.
The approach culminated in the exceptional success of 1982… With a Bullet. The album reached number one on the Australian chart and remained there for five weeks. It demonstrated that a thoughtfully compiled, strongly titled and heavily advertised collection could compete with—and outsell—new albums by individual artists.
Creating the commercials
A central creative contributor to the campaigns was Billy Birmingham, EMI (Australia)’s promotions manager. His experience in record promotion meant that he understood what EMI (Australia) needed to sell, while his advertising instincts enabled him to translate that information into commercials capable of making an immediate impression.
Peter and Billy worked together from the conception of each campaign. They identified the album’s strongest selling points, considered its audience and developed the way it should be presented. Billy then created the television commercials that carried those ideas into Australian homes.
"He did all the commercials for all our TV campaigns and we sort of conceived them together. He was a complete genius and he made the most marvellous TV commercials.
"Of course, he went on to become an even bigger star with things like Austen Tayshus, the Twelfth Man and funny things like that."